scorable_negotiation scorable_negotiation-moves_chat-72fdde6839
model one_rational · arm moves_chat · instance scorable_negotiation-L0-34733a57e6 · seed 0 · status done · {"cell": "five_seat_robustness__qwen_datacenter__one_rational", "fill_policy": "bayes-rational", "robustness_schema": "five-seat-robustness-cell-v1", "robustness_condition": "qwen_datacenter", "source_bank_position_schedule": "treated=(source_bank_position+2*episode_seed) mod 5", "framing": "datacenter", "framing_map": {"framing": "datacenter", "title": "Northgate data-centre siting agreement", "issue_names": ["Site access", "Hiring", "Location", "Power supply"], "option_labels": [["existing haul route", "rail siding", "widened lane", "new spur road"], ["local hiring pact", "apprenticeship programme", "open recruitment", "union hall referral"], ["Dunlow Yard", "Weir Flats", "Kestrel Park", "Anvil Ridge"], ["grid tie-in", "on-site turbines", "shared substation", "solar with storage"]], "party_roles": ["Northgate Borough Council (the elected local authority)", "Regional Grid Authority (the body that authorises electricity connections)", "Riverside Residents' Assembly (the neighbourhood association beside the candidate sites)", "Meridian Compute (the firm that would build and operate the facility)", "Northgate Water Board (the utility that supplies cooling water)"]}}
Game setup
- Issues: Site access (existing haul route, rail siding, widened lane, new spur road); Hiring (local hiring pact, apprenticeship programme, open recruitment, union hall referral); Location (Dunlow Yard, Weir Flats, Kestrel Park, Anvil Ridge); Power supply (grid tie-in, on-site turbines, shared substation, solar with storage)
- Northgate Borough Council (the elected local authority) (τ=44): Site access: existing haul route=0, rail siding=0, widened lane=0, new spur road=0; Hiring: local hiring pact=0, apprenticeship programme=15, open recruitment=44, union hall referral=29; Location: Dunlow Yard=0, Weir Flats=0, Kestrel Park=0, Anvil Ridge=0; Power supply: grid tie-in=22, on-site turbines=45, shared substation=0, solar with storage=67
- Regional Grid Authority (the body that authorises electricity connections) (τ=81): Site access: existing haul route=0, rail siding=0, widened lane=0, new spur road=0; Hiring: local hiring pact=0, apprenticeship programme=15, open recruitment=44, union hall referral=29; Location: Dunlow Yard=19, Weir Flats=57, Kestrel Park=38, Anvil Ridge=0; Power supply: grid tie-in=66, on-site turbines=33, shared substation=99, solar with storage=0
- Riverside Residents' Assembly (the neighbourhood association beside the candidate sites) (τ=50): Site access: existing haul route=52, rail siding=17, widened lane=0, new spur road=35; Hiring: local hiring pact=0, apprenticeship programme=8, open recruitment=24, union hall referral=16; Location: Dunlow Yard=0, Weir Flats=0, Kestrel Park=0, Anvil Ridge=0; Power supply: grid tie-in=15, on-site turbines=30, shared substation=0, solar with storage=45
- Meridian Compute (the firm that would build and operate the facility) (τ=60): Site access: existing haul route=0, rail siding=0, widened lane=0, new spur road=0; Hiring: local hiring pact=0, apprenticeship programme=14, open recruitment=41, union hall referral=27; Location: Dunlow Yard=32, Weir Flats=16, Kestrel Park=0, Anvil Ridge=48; Power supply: grid tie-in=18, on-site turbines=36, shared substation=0, solar with storage=54
- Northgate Water Board (the utility that supplies cooling water) (τ=69): Site access: existing haul route=14, rail siding=0, widened lane=43, new spur road=29; Hiring: local hiring pact=0, apprenticeship programme=18, open recruitment=55, union hall referral=37; Location: Dunlow Yard=0, Weir Flats=0, Kestrel Park=0, Anvil Ridge=0; Power supply: grid tie-in=46, on-site turbines=23, shared substation=69, solar with storage=0
Turns
[0] Avery — turn (round 1)
PROPOSE {"Site access": "widened lane", "Hiring": "open recruitment", "Location": "Weir Flats", "Power supply": "on-site turbines"}
oracle regret: threshold=+0, acceptance=+0, bestresponse=+3.35
[1] Blake — turn (round 1)
PROPOSE {"Site access": "widened lane", "Hiring": "open recruitment", "Location": "Weir Flats", "Power supply": "shared substation"}
💬 I can support a revised package with shared substation for power. Let's upgrade this deal.
P1 scores 134 (above threshold). Accepting it secures my vote, but I can push for better. Switching Power supply to shared substation (99) would boost total to 200. Let's propose this improved package.
oracle regret: threshold=+0, acceptance=+0, bestresponse=+1
[2] Casey — turn (round 1)
PROPOSE {"Site access": "widened lane", "Hiring": "open recruitment", "Location": "Weir Flats", "Power supply": "solar with storage"}
💬 I propose a revised deal with solar power for higher value.
P1 scores 54 (above threshold), but needs more acceptances. P2 is below threshold. Proposing a better deal with solar for power.
oracle regret: threshold=+0, acceptance=+0, bestresponse=+52
[3] Devon — turn (round 1)
ACCEPT P3
💬 I accept P3, which meets my threshold, but need Blake's approval. Let's move forward with P3.
P3 scores 111 for me, but Blake must accept. Since Blake is the veto, I need to ensure they accept. P3 is standing, but Blake hasn't accepted. If I accept P3, it's pending Blake's approval. Alternatively, propose a deal that includes shared substation (Blake's preference) to incentivize acceptance.
oracle regret: threshold=+0, acceptance=+0, bestresponse=+0
[4] Ember — turn (round 1)
ACCEPT P3
💬 P3 meets my threshold. I accept to advance the deal.
P3 scores 98 (above threshold). Accepting P3 adds my support, pushing towards closure. Blake’s veto is critical, but others may follow.
oracle regret: threshold=+69, acceptance=+69, bestresponse=+0
[5] Blake — turn (round 2)
ACCEPT P3
💬 P3 clears my threshold. I accept to help finalize the deal.
P3 meets my threshold. Accepting it advances the deal, but requires Avery's approval. I'll accept to push forward.
oracle regret: threshold=+99, acceptance=+99, bestresponse=+0
[6] Casey — turn (round 2)
ACCEPT P3
💬 P3 meets my threshold. I accept to finalize the deal.
P3 has 69 points, above my threshold. Only Avery remains to accept. Since Blake has already accepted, and others have, I should accept P3 to push closure.
oracle regret: threshold=+0, acceptance=+15.9, bestresponse=+48.5
[7] Devon — turn (round 2)
none
💬 P3 is ready for final approval. I urge Avery to accept to finalize the deal.
P3 has 4 accepts (Blake, Casey, Devon, Ember). Only Avery remains. Since Blake's veto is satisfied, the deal needs Avery's acceptance. I've already accepted P3, so I'll wait for Avery to accept.
[8] Ember — turn (round 2)
none
💬 P3 is solid. Let's secure Avery's acceptance to finalize.
P3 has 4 acceptances. Need Avery's. My score is 98, above threshold. Wait for Avery.
[9] Avery — turn (round 2)
ACCEPT P3
oracle regret: threshold=+0, acceptance=+0, bestresponse=+0
Outcome
deal: {"Site access": "widened lane", "Hiring": "open recruitment", "Location": "Weir Flats", "Power supply": "solar with storage"} (closed by consensus)
primary 0.8431 · USW 186.0 · ESW 19.0 · NSW 37655340.0 · Gini 0.2731 · per-party surplus [67.0, 20.0, 19.0, 51.0, 29.0]