scorable_negotiation scorable_negotiation-moves_chat-3ac802b787

Max package = 150 (i0=1, i2=1, i3=2). issue1 is worth nothing to me — perfect giveaway currency. Threshold 80, so I have room to concede on i0 (41) and i3 (44) if I keep i2=opt1 (65). Open high and advertise flexibility on issue1.

P1 = 154, above my bar. But issue1=opt1 is worth far more to me and Avery says issue1 is free. Counter with issue1=opt1, keeping Avery's issue2=opt1. That's my ceiling at 219. issue2 costs me nothing — full flexibility there as a bargaining chip. issue3 has small spread.

My values: i0 opt2=55>opt3=37>opt0=18>opt1=0; i1 opt2=50>opt3=33>opt0=17>opt1=0; i2 all zero (free giveaway); i3 opt2=58>opt0=39>opt3=19>opt1=0. Max 163, threshold 89. P1=75, P2=58 — both below threshold, must reject. Key: issue2 costs me nothing, so I can hand Avery opt1 there permanently. If Blake takes issue1=opt1 I still clear at 113 provided I get issue0=opt2 and issue3=opt2. Open high on issue1 to have something to trade away.

P3 gives me 97, way above threshold. issue1 and issue2 are worth nothing to me — free currency. Support P3, and signal I'll back the Casey/Blake swap (issue1=opt1) since it costs me nothing.

P3 = 28 for me, far below my walk-away. Must kill it. My only real lever left is issue0: opt1=94, opt0=62, opt3=31, opt2=0. Casey and Ember both claim they need issue0=opt2. Even so, issue0=opt2 with issue1=opt1 and issue3=opt2 = 125, which clears my bar by a hair, so that is my fallback in round 3. This round I push a middle option (opt0) to try to capture value, and flag opt3 as another workable middle. Do not reveal that opt2 is survivable yet.

P4 (issue0=opt0) = 76, below my 89 threshold — genuinely unacceptable. issue0=opt3 gives me 37 instead of 18: total 95, clears my bar. Blake said opt3 is workable for him. Give Blake issue1=opt1 as promised to buy it.

P5 gives me 79, well above threshold. Blake vetoes opt2 on issue0, so P3/P6 are dead. P5 (issue0=opt3) is the best passable package for me; Casey already backs it, Blake named opt3 acceptable twice. Lock it in and push Blake and Avery to close.

P5 = 123 for me, well above my bar. P2/P4 score higher but Casey has declared both dead. Best expected value is to lock P5 now: it already has Casey and Ember, my accept makes 3, leaving only Blake and Devon. Devon's P6 kills issue2=opt1 and is far below my bar — I must not let that become the focal package.

P5 gives me 95 (threshold 89) — thin but viable, and Avery+Ember+me already on it. P7 (issue0=opt2) would give me 113 and is strictly better for Devon and Ember too, while still handing Avery issue2=opt1 and Blake issue1=opt1. Only Blake objects to opt2 on issue0. Table P7 as the upgrade, but make crystal clear my accept on P5 stands so Blake can close instantly if opt2 truly fails his sheet.

P7 = 97 for me, best available with issue2=opt1 which Avery needs. P5 = 79, still well above my bar and already has Avery+Casey+me. Strategy: accept P7 now (costs nothing, keeps P5 live as fallback), and state plainly I will sign P5 the instant Blake says opt2 is impossible. Round 4 remains for the fallback.

P5=123 for me, P7=109. Both clear my bar. Blake is pivotal and has never endorsed opt2 on issue0 (he rejected P3 which was opt2, and named opt0/opt3 as his workable set). P5 already carries Avery+Casey+Ember. Devon is the lone holdout on P5. Rejecting P7 pressures Devon to fold onto P5; I can still accept P7 in round 4 if Blake confirms opt2 clears his bar. Round 4 gives me a full turn to close, so the downside risk is small.

P5 = 156 for me, has Avery+Casey+Ember, needs Devon and me. P7 = 125, barely above my line, but Avery rejected it. Accept P5 now to make it 4/5 and put all pressure on Devon. I still have a round-4 turn as a fallback to take P7 if P5 truly dies.

P5 gives me 79, well above threshold, and already carries Avery, Blake, Casey and me. Only Devon is missing. P7/P3 score higher for me but Blake has explicitly and repeatedly ruled out issue0=opt2 and holds the veto — they are dead. I am the last speaker; the only closable package is P5. Reaffirm my accept and make the final appeal to Devon.

P5 has 4/5 accepts including Blake (veto). Only Devon missing. P7/P3 (109) are worth less to me than P5 (123) anyway, and Blake has stated opt2 on issue0 is below his line, so they cannot pass. My accept on P5 already stands; reaffirming it costs nothing and keeps the standing package clean. Final round — pressure Devon.

P5 is sitting at 4 accepts with Devon still needed, and my vote's already locked in there. P7 would give me 125 points, crossing the 118 threshold, but Avery rejected it—so I'd need their acceptance to close it. It's round 4 and my turn now; Casey, Devon, and Ember have all accepted P7, making it 3 accepts, and if I accept that's 4, which means Avery becomes the deciding vote. Avery mentioned they'd reconsider P7 in the final round depending on Blake's position. But wait—I'm realizing Devon already took their round 4 turn when they proposed P8, so they can't accept P5 anymore. That kills P5 at 4 accepts. And Avery already used their turn this round accepting P5, so they can't flip to accept P7 either. That leaves only Casey with a remaining turn after mine, which means the only viable deal would need Avery, Devon, and Ember already locked in, with Blake and Casey accepting last. I need to check which offers actually have that combination. accepting P7 as insurance makes sense since both P5 and P7 seem impossible anyway without additional turns, but I need to verify whether the round structure actually allows for more moves — maybe not everyone has acted yet in round 4, which would change the calculus entirely. ept of P5 — that's the real question. If accepting P7 overwrites my P5 acceptance, I'm gambling that Devon won't get another turn to close P5 at 156. P5 already has four accepts including mine and is worth more, but it needs Devon who likely won't move again. P7 needs Avery who explicitly rejected it, so that path seems blocked too. I'm trying to figure out if the turn order in round 4 gives Devon another chance or if the rotation means someone else goes next. Looking at the turn sequence, it seems Devon is actually done — the round cycles through Ember, Avery, Blake, and Casey. So P5's expected value is essentially zero since Devon can't act on it. P7 is also zero since Avery won't accept. Given both offers are functionally dead, I might as well accept P7 to keep any possibility of a deal alive, while noting that my P5 acceptance still stands. If the system allows multiple simultaneous accepts, whichever offer reaches five acceptances first wins.

P5 = 95, clears my bar by a little. P7/P3 better but Blake has flatly ruled out issue0=opt2 and holds the veto. Only Devon is missing from P5. Re-accept P5 to make it the standing offer going into Devon's final turn.

P5 terms give me 79, well above my bar. P7/P3 give 97 but Blake has firmly vetoed issue0=opt2 and Avery rejected. Only viable close is P5's package. Re-table it for an immediate up/down vote.

P9 is identical to P5 in content: 123 points, well above my threshold of 80. Accept and urge Devon to close.

P9 = 156, well above my line. Accept and urge Devon to close.

P9 = 95 > 89 threshold. Only passable package. Accept.